Briefly state which Debate point had the ‘best’ evidence to support your initial idea & why? How would you define the topic based on what you already know?

How would you define the topic based on what you already know?

What is your viewpoint or position on this topic?

Watch the ‘Debate’ and ask any questions you have, etc.

Based on your previous thoughts and information discussed during the Debate, develop a ‘Position Summary’ that includes the following points.

Define the topic

Describe why this topic is controversial

State your initial viewpoint on the topic and why you feel this way.

Briefly state which Debate point had the ‘best’ evidence to support your initial idea & why?

Briefly state which Debate point had the ‘best’ evidence to refute your initial idea & why?

Even if you don’t agree, state which position had the most convincing evidence & why?

Discuss how this debate has impacted your opinion.

Analyze an historical issue from the first half of U.S. History (pre-1877). You will need to compare at least two opposing perspectives on that issue.

Controversial Debate

What is the main argument in each perspective? On what points do they agree or
disagree?
Analyze the evidence that is provided to support each.What types of
evidence are used? Does the evidence support?
Genre and
Disciplinary
Conventions

Analyze an historical issue from the first half of U.S. History (pre-1877). You will
need to compare at least two opposing perspectives on that issue.

Analyze an historical issue from the first half of U.S. History (pre-1877). You will
need to compare at least two opposing perspectives on that issue. Analyze the
evidence that is provided to support each. What types of evidence are
used? Does the evidence support the?