Structured evaluative piece of writing based on a research paper.
Full paper:
Questions to be answered;
1. Briefly summarise the main findings described in this paper
(Indicative length approx. 150 words)
2. In Figure 1C the authors use siRNA to reduce UCHL1 levels in cells. Briefly describe how
siRNA can reduce UCHL1 expression and suggest two alternative approaches the authors could
have used, outlining how they work, their benefits and their limitations.
(Indicative length approx. 250 words)
3. Pick the figure (relates to an entire figure (e.g Fig 1 or Fig 2 etc) and not the individual panels (e.g 1A, 1B or 1C etc)) that you think is the most important. Describe the results, the experimental
approach(es) used and why you think that it is the key figure in the paper.
(Indicative length approx. 300 words).
4. Draw and briefly discuss the signalling pathway delineated in this study and how this adds to
what was previously known about HIF regulation.
(Indicative length: Figure plus approx. 300 words)
5. What are the physiological, pathophysiological and therapeutic implications of this study?
(Indicative length approx. 300 words)